Machine Learning: Optimal Length [YinYangAlgorithms]

2023년 11월 20일

This Indicator aims to solve an issue that most others face; static lengths. This Indicator will scan lengths from the Min to Max setting (1 - 400 by default) to calculate which is the most Optimal Length in the current market condition. Almost every Indicator uses a length in some part of their calculation, and this length is usually adjustable via the Settings; however it is generally a static fixed length. Static non changing lengths may not always produce optimal results. As market conditions change generally the optimal length will too. For this reason we have created this indicator.

This Indicator will create a Neutral (Min - Max Length), Fast (Min - Mid Length ((Max - Min) / 2)) and Slow (Mid Length ((Max - Min) / 2) - Max Length). This allows you to understand which the Optimal Fast, Slow and Neutral lengths are within the given Mix and Max length settings.

This Indicator then plots these Optimal Lengths as an Oscillator which can then be used within ANOTHER Indicator as a Source within its Settings. Stand alone this Indicator may not prove all that useful, however when its Lengths are inputted into another Indicator it may prove very useful. This allows other Indicators to use the Optimal Length within its calculations from the Settings rather than relying on simply a fixed length. Unfortunately this results in users needing to manually plug the Optimal Length plots into the second Indicator; but it also allows for endless possibilities with applying Machine Learning Optimal Lengths within both Traditional and Non-Traditional Indicators and may give other Pine Coders an easy and effective way to add Machine Learning auto adjustable lengths within their already created Indicators.

The beautiful part about this Indicator is that aside from inputting the Optimal Length Plot into another Indicator, there is no manual updating needed. When the Optimal Length changes, the change will automatically reflect in the other Indicator without the need for you to manually adjust its length. This may be very useful with both time preservation, as well as if there is an automated strategy based upon said Indicator that now won’t need manual intervention.

Tutorial:



By default this is what the Machine Learning: Optimal Length Indicator looks like. It is simply a way of both Displaying and Plotting our current Optimal Length so that we may then use it as a source within ANOTHER Indicator. This will allow the automation of an Optimal Length to be updated, rather than needing any manual input from yourself (aside from set up).

For instance if you set the start length to 1 and the end length to 400 (default settings), it will scan to find the optimal Length setting between 1 and 400. This features 3 types of lengths:

• Fast (Green Line): 1-199 (from start length to half way of total)
  
• Slow (Red Line): 200 - 400 (mid way to end length)
  
• Neutral (Blue Line): 1 - 400 (start to end length)
  

By breaking down the Optimal Length detection into these 3 different types, we can see how the Optimal Length compares and changes based on the lengths allotted to them and how performance changes.

For instance, you may notice that both the Fast and Slow Optimal Length didn’t change much in the example above; however the Neutral Optimal Length changed quite a bit. This is due to the fact that the Neutral is inclusive of all lengths available and may be considered the more accurate due to that. However, this doesn’t mean the Fast and Slow lengths aren’t important and should be used. They may be useful for seeing how something fairs in a Fast and Slow standpoint.



If you change your TimeFrame from 15 minute to 1 Day, you’ll notice that the Optimal Lengths gravitate towards their upper bounds:
199 is max for Fast, it’s at 195
400 is max for Slow, its at 393
400 is max for Neutral, its at 399
The Optimal Length may move up to its upper bounds on Higher Time Frames because there is a lot of price action and long term data being displayed. This may lead to higher lengths performing better in a profitability standpoint since its data is based on so far back and such drastic price movements.

Below we’re going to go through a few examples, including the code so you may reproduce the example and have an understanding of how versatile Inputting an Optimal Length as a source may be within Traditional Indicators.

Adding the Machine Learning: Optimal Length to another Indicator:



You may add the Optimal Length to another Indicator as shown in the example above. In the example we are adding the ‘Machine Learning: Optimal Length - Neutral’ to our Neutral Length within the Settings. The external Indicator needs to have the ability to input the Optimal Length as a Source, this way it can automatically change within the external Indicator when the Optimal Length Indicator changes its Optimal Length.

Please note you may get an error within an external Indicator that accepts the Length as a Source if you don’t select the Machine Learning: Optimal Length. For instance, if you use ‘Close’ within BTC/USDT the length used would be ~36,000. This length is too long and will throw an error.

For this reason, we will ensure the Max Length that may be used is 1000.

Please note, on lower Time Frames you may need to adjust the Max Length. For instance if 20k bar data is used, the Max Length ‘may’ fail to load when going by default Min: 1 and Max: 400. Generally with most pairs it will load if your TradingView subscription is Premium or greater; however if it is less there is a chance it may fail. If it fails for you too often please lower the Max Length Amount; or send us a message we can look into a fix for this.

*** If it fails to load, please try removing the external Indicator and re-adding it and adding the Lengths back as a Source within the Settings. Sometimes it fails, but re-adding may fix it. If it keeps failing afterwards, reduce the Max Length Amount as mentioned above. ***

Simple Moving Average:




In this example above have the Fast, Slow and Neutral Optimal Length formatted as a Slow Moving Average. The first example is on the 15 minute Time Frame and the second is on the 1 Day Time Frame, demonstrating how the length changes based on the Time Frame and the effects it may have.

Here is the code for the example Indicator shown above. This example shows how you may use the Optimal Length as a Source and then use that Optimal Length and plot it as a Simple Moving Average:

Pine Script®

Bollinger Bands:




In the two examples above for Bollinger Bands we have first the 15 Minute Time Frame and then the 1 Day Time Frame. As described above in ‘Adding the Machine Learning: Optimal Length to another Indicator’ sometimes it may fail to load, for this reason in the 15 Minute it was reduced to a max of 300 Length.

Bollinger Bands are a way to see a Simple Moving Average (SMA) that then uses Standard Deviation to identify how much deviation has occurred. This Deviation is than Added and Subtracted from the SMA to create the Bollinger Bands which help Identify possible movement zones that are ‘within range’. This may mean that the price may face Support / Resistance when it reaches the Outer / Inner bounds of the Bollinger Bands. Likewise, it may mean the Price is ‘Overbought’ when outside and above or ‘Underbought’ when outside and below the Bollinger Bands.

By applying All 3 different types of Optimal Lengths towards a Traditional Bollinger Band calculation we may hope to see different ranges of Bollinger Bands and how different lookback lengths may imply possible movement ranges on both a Short Term, Long Term and Neutral perspective. By seeing these possible ranges you may have the ability to identify more levels of Support and Resistance over different lengths and Trading Styles.

Below is the code for the Bollinger Bands example above:

Pine Script®

Donchian Channels:




Above you’ll see two examples of Machine Learning: Optimal Length applied to Donchian Channels. These are displayed with both the 15 Minute Time Frame and the 1 Day Time Frame.

Donchian Channels are a way of seeing potential Support and Resistance within a given lookback length. They are a way of withholding the High’s and Low’s of a specific lookback length and looking for deviation within this length. By applying our Fast, Slow and Neutral Machine Learning: Optimal Length to these Donchian Channels way may hope to achieve a viable range of High’s and Low’s that one may use to Identify Support and Resistance locations for different ranges of Optimal Lengths and likewise potentially different Trading Strategies.

The code to reproduce these Donchian Channels as displayed above is so:

Pine Script®

Envelopes / Envelopes Adjusted:

Envelopes are an interesting one in the sense that they both may be perceived as useful; however we deem that with the use of an ‘Optimal Length’ that the ‘Envelopes Adjusted’ may work best. We will start with examples of the Traditional Envelope then showcase the Adjusted version.

Envelopes:




As you may see, a Traditional form of Envelopes even produced with our Machine Learning: Optimal Length may not produce optimal results. Unfortunately this may occur with some Traditional Indicators and they may need some adjustments as you’ll notice with the ‘Envelopes Adjusted’ version. However, even without the adjustments, these Envelopes may be useful for seeing ‘Overbought’ and ‘Oversold’ locations within a Machine Learning: Optimal Length standpoint.

Envelopes Adjusted:




By adding an adjustment to these Envelopes, we may hope to better reflect out Optimal Length within it. This is caused by adding a ratio reflection towards the current length of the Optimal Length and the max Length used. This allows for the Fast and Neutral (and potentially Slow if Neutral is greater) to achieve a potentially more accurate result.

Envelopes, much like Bollinger Bands are a way of seeing potential movement zones along with potential Support and Resistance. However, unlike Bollinger Bands which are based on Standard Deviation, Envelopes are based on percentages +/- from the Simple Moving Average.

The code used to reproduce the example above is as follows:

Pine Script®

Hopefully these examples, including reproducing code, have given you some insight as to how useful this Machine Learning: Optimal Length may be and how another Indicator may easily modify their existing code to incorporate the usage of such Machine Learning: Optimal Length. We likewise will publish a Backtesting Indicator which incorporates all of the concepts we’ve gone over within here; in case you wish to take advantage of the Traditional Indicators mentioned above that allow the input of Machine Learning: Optimal Length and don’t wish to code them.

If you have any questions, comments, ideas or concerns please don't hesitate to contact us.

HAPPY TRADING!

2023년 12월 5일

릴리즈 노트

- Fixed an issue with Slow and Fast displaying an error on some Indicators.