Indicator Insights Part 4: Modified MACD
업데이트됨
In this fourth instalment of our Indicator Insights series, we delve into the Modified MACD, a refinement of the classic MACD (Moving Average Convergence Divergence) introduced by Market Wizard Linda Raschke and trading author Adam H. Grimes. This modification aims to provide traders with a more streamlined and focused tool for trend reversal identification and momentum analysis.
Understanding the Modified MACD
The Modified MACD maintains the essence of the traditional MACD while introducing specific adjustments to enhance its effectiveness. It comprises three key components: the Fast Line, the Signal Line, and the Zero Line.
Fast Line Calculation:
The Fast Line is determined by taking the difference between the 3-period Simple Moving Average (SMA) and the 10-period SMA. This shorter time frame allows the Fast Line to respond more swiftly to recent price changes, capturing short-term momentum.
Signal Line Calculation:
The Signal Line is a 16-period SMA of the Fast Line. It provides a smoothed representation of the Fast Line's trend, offering insights into the overall momentum direction.
Zero Line Reference:
The Zero Line serves as a reference point on the indicator. Crossovers above the Zero Line may indicate bullish momentum, while crossovers below suggest bearish momentum.
Modified MACD
Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results
Standard MACD Settings Comparison:
To appreciate the modifications, let's compare the Modified MACD settings with the standard MACD settings:
Standard MACD:
Modified MACD:
Modified Versus Standard MACD
Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results
Advantages of the Modified MACD
Simplicity and Clarity:
By omitting the histogram, the Modified MACD offers a cleaner representation of the relationship between the Fast Line and the Signal Line. This simplicity aids traders in making clearer interpretations of trend strength.
Faster Response:
The use of a 3-period SMA in the Fast Line provides a faster response to recent price changes. This responsiveness can be advantageous in capturing short-term trends and potential reversal points.
Identifying Trend Reversals with Modified MACD
Using the modified MACD in combination with price action analysis can be useful when predicting the end of a trend.
Bearish Trend Reversal
A bearish trend reversal is when an uptrend comes to an end. If a pullback against the uptrend has the following three characteristics, it may be predictive of a change in trend:
1. New Momentum Low: The fast line prints a new momentum low on the modified MACD during the pullback.
2. Signal Line Slopes Down: The signal line starts to slope down as prices consolidate following the pullback.
3. Market Consolidates Sideways: If the pullback against the uptrend, which recorded a new momentum low on the modified MACD, is followed by a period of sideways consolidation in which the uptrend fails to resume, this is a bearish sign.
Worked Example: EUR/USD Bearish Trend Reversal
Here we have EUR/USD on the daily candle chart, prices had been trending higher before the market put in a pullback which printed a new momentum low on the modified MACD. It’s worth noting here that MACD is a boundless indicator so we can’t set upper and lower bounds, but recent swings are good approximations of new momentum low and highs. The slope of the signal line started to point downwards and following the pullback, the market failed to resume the uptrend – consolidating sideways instead. These factors signalled a potential change in short-term trend.
EUR/USD Daily Candle Chart
Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results
Bullish Trend Reversal
The opposite applies to bullish trend reversals where a downtrend comes to an end. If a pullback against the downtrend has the following three characteristics, it may be predictive of a change in trend:
1. New Momentum High: The fast line prints a new momentum high on the modified MACD during the pullback.
2. Signal Line Slopes Up: The signal line starts to slope up as prices consolidate following the pullback.
3. Market Consolidates Sideways: If the pullback against the downtrend, which recorded a new momentum high on the modified MACD, is followed by a period of sideways consolidation in which the uptrend fails to resume, this is a bullish sign.
Worked Example: EUR/USD Bearish Trend Reversal
Keeping with the same market and same timeframe as before, we can see that our bearish trend reversal signal was followed by a bullish trend reversal signal. The market put in a pullback against the downtrend which printed a new momentum high on the modified MACD’s fast line. The market then consolidated sideways and failed to resume its uptrend – giving time for the signal line of the modified MACD to start moving higher. These factors signalled a potential change in trend.
EUR/USD Daily Candle Chart
Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results
Summary:
The Modified MACD, pioneered by Linda Raschke, introduces a simplified yet effective approach to momentum analysis, emphasising clarity and faster response to recent price changes. During pullbacks in trends, traders can leverage new momentum highs and lows on the fast line, along with a change in slope of the signal line for actionable insights into potential trend reversals.
Understanding the Modified MACD
The Modified MACD maintains the essence of the traditional MACD while introducing specific adjustments to enhance its effectiveness. It comprises three key components: the Fast Line, the Signal Line, and the Zero Line.
Fast Line Calculation:
The Fast Line is determined by taking the difference between the 3-period Simple Moving Average (SMA) and the 10-period SMA. This shorter time frame allows the Fast Line to respond more swiftly to recent price changes, capturing short-term momentum.
Signal Line Calculation:
The Signal Line is a 16-period SMA of the Fast Line. It provides a smoothed representation of the Fast Line's trend, offering insights into the overall momentum direction.
Zero Line Reference:
The Zero Line serves as a reference point on the indicator. Crossovers above the Zero Line may indicate bullish momentum, while crossovers below suggest bearish momentum.
Modified MACD
Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results
Standard MACD Settings Comparison:
To appreciate the modifications, let's compare the Modified MACD settings with the standard MACD settings:
Standard MACD:
- Fast Line: 12-period EMA minus 26-period EMA
- Signal Line: 9-period EMA of the MACD Line
- Histogram: Represents the difference between the MACD Line and the Signal Line
Modified MACD:
- Fast Line: 3-period SMA minus 10-period SMA
- Signal Line: 16-period SMA of the Fast Line
- No Histogram: Simplifies the indicator for a cleaner representation
- Zero Line: Reference for potential bullish or bearish momentum
Modified Versus Standard MACD
Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results
Advantages of the Modified MACD
Simplicity and Clarity:
By omitting the histogram, the Modified MACD offers a cleaner representation of the relationship between the Fast Line and the Signal Line. This simplicity aids traders in making clearer interpretations of trend strength.
Faster Response:
The use of a 3-period SMA in the Fast Line provides a faster response to recent price changes. This responsiveness can be advantageous in capturing short-term trends and potential reversal points.
Identifying Trend Reversals with Modified MACD
Using the modified MACD in combination with price action analysis can be useful when predicting the end of a trend.
Bearish Trend Reversal
A bearish trend reversal is when an uptrend comes to an end. If a pullback against the uptrend has the following three characteristics, it may be predictive of a change in trend:
1. New Momentum Low: The fast line prints a new momentum low on the modified MACD during the pullback.
2. Signal Line Slopes Down: The signal line starts to slope down as prices consolidate following the pullback.
3. Market Consolidates Sideways: If the pullback against the uptrend, which recorded a new momentum low on the modified MACD, is followed by a period of sideways consolidation in which the uptrend fails to resume, this is a bearish sign.
Worked Example: EUR/USD Bearish Trend Reversal
Here we have EUR/USD on the daily candle chart, prices had been trending higher before the market put in a pullback which printed a new momentum low on the modified MACD. It’s worth noting here that MACD is a boundless indicator so we can’t set upper and lower bounds, but recent swings are good approximations of new momentum low and highs. The slope of the signal line started to point downwards and following the pullback, the market failed to resume the uptrend – consolidating sideways instead. These factors signalled a potential change in short-term trend.
EUR/USD Daily Candle Chart
Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results
Bullish Trend Reversal
The opposite applies to bullish trend reversals where a downtrend comes to an end. If a pullback against the downtrend has the following three characteristics, it may be predictive of a change in trend:
1. New Momentum High: The fast line prints a new momentum high on the modified MACD during the pullback.
2. Signal Line Slopes Up: The signal line starts to slope up as prices consolidate following the pullback.
3. Market Consolidates Sideways: If the pullback against the downtrend, which recorded a new momentum high on the modified MACD, is followed by a period of sideways consolidation in which the uptrend fails to resume, this is a bullish sign.
Worked Example: EUR/USD Bearish Trend Reversal
Keeping with the same market and same timeframe as before, we can see that our bearish trend reversal signal was followed by a bullish trend reversal signal. The market put in a pullback against the downtrend which printed a new momentum high on the modified MACD’s fast line. The market then consolidated sideways and failed to resume its uptrend – giving time for the signal line of the modified MACD to start moving higher. These factors signalled a potential change in trend.
EUR/USD Daily Candle Chart
Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results
Summary:
The Modified MACD, pioneered by Linda Raschke, introduces a simplified yet effective approach to momentum analysis, emphasising clarity and faster response to recent price changes. During pullbacks in trends, traders can leverage new momentum highs and lows on the fast line, along with a change in slope of the signal line for actionable insights into potential trend reversals.
노트
Disclaimer: This is for information and learning purposes only and is intended for UK audiences. The information provided does not constitute investment advice nor take into account the individual financial circumstances or objectives of any investor. Any information that may be provided relating to past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results or performance. Social media channels are not relevant for UK residents.Spread bets and CFDs are complex instruments and come with a high risk of losing money rapidly due to leverage. 75% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading spread bets and CFDs with this provider. You should consider whether you understand how spread bets and CFDs work and whether you can afford to take the high risk of losing your money.
면책사항
이 정보와 게시물은 TradingView에서 제공하거나 보증하는 금융, 투자, 거래 또는 기타 유형의 조언이나 권고 사항을 의미하거나 구성하지 않습니다. 자세한 내용은 이용 약관을 참고하세요.